Every August in Lake Potawatomi, Wisconsin, there's a baking contest, and baker-turned-mystery writer Teddie St. John has a pie in the ring. Then the head judge Les Morris is found dead with his face half-buried in a delectable coconut cream pie, and Teddie's distinctive embossed rolling pin is nearby, covered with blood. In this sequel to Murder Most Sweet, Teddie needs to act fast, and this time, her quick wit and bohemian charm won't save her from the law—or the real killer.