Love is in the air as library director Lindsey and boat captain Sully are finally tying the knot. When Lindsey and her crafternoon pals head out to Bell Island to see if it can accommodate the ever-expanding guest list, they are horrified to discover a body. Even worse, Lindsey recognizes the man as the justice of the peace who was supposed to officiate her wedding. Now she has to solve the mystery before it ends her happily ever.